You are a sweetheart.
“I would have loved for Emma’s fiancee to be genuine, it would have been so interesting to find out how she would have dealt with falling in love with someone else then suddenly remembering Hook and what he would’ve done, it feels as if the writers didn’t know what to make of it so they just undid it.”
I would have loved this with either Tamara or Walsh. The fact that they gave both Neal and Emma ‘just kidding their really only with you for evil reasons’ SOs is redundant and unrealistic and boring.
I would have loved for Emma to have a real struggle with this good life she and Henry have, with Walsh and their lives and normal, versus believing in the curse and leaving everything for what they had before. There could have been beautiful realistic storytelling; we never saw Emma have to give up a life to accept Storybrooke, but this could have been so interesting. And until those last moments Walsh seemed like a good guy.
I would have liked it with Neal too, if Tamara was a good person. if Emma and Neal dealt with each other as friends and coparents first, and we got a real reaction from someone on he outside learning about Storybrooke.
“When I saw that it was Henry who didn’t believe Emma about a curse this season I felt like shouting ‘Henry you stupid boy, now you see how stupid it sounds’ at my screen”
Henry, at the age of ten, figured out what was wrong in town, figured out how to leave, got Emma to come back with him, figured out who many people were. He’s a clever kid.
Why exactly is he stupid?
To be honest, as smart as he was to work it out, honestly expecting people to believe him was a little naive. Cause it does sound stupid if you don’t know it is real.
But then I think that is part of him having such faith, when you believe like that it is hard to see why other people don’t.
It’s completely understandable for people in canon not to believe him. It does sound ridiculous. I totally think Emma, Archie et all were right to doubt him.
What I don’t understand is someone watching the show calling Henry stupid when all canon is to the contrary. It’s not the fact that it sounds impossible, but the “Henry you stupid boy’ that I don’t understand.
Neither one of them is perfect, and they are not perfect together. But then I wouldn’t want them to be perfect.
I don’t like that they haven’t ha a lot of time together. I don’t like that Rum’s first impulse was to keep her to himself, though considering everything that’s happened I understand why he did it.
Mostly I just want them to have time to learn about each other and grow. I hope they don’t rush into marriage/kids etc.
Imagine Teddy getting a howler from Tonks and he starts to freak out but when he opens it, it’s like
TEDDY GUESS WHAT, THE WEIRD SISTERS ARE COMING TO TOWN. PACK YOUR THINGS, SON, I ALREADY TALKED TO MCGONAGALL AND SHE SAID IT’S COOL. MERLIN’S PANTS I’M SO EXCITED. DON’T TELL ANYONE OKAY, MAYBE YOU SHOULDN’T TELL DAD EITHER. OH FUCK, IS THIS A HOWLER? I FUCKED UP, I FUCKED UP.
And Remus at the teachers table covering his face to hide his laughter.
I’m laughing and crying at the same time.
HOW DARE YOU! THIS ISN’T OKAY.